A FORMER Police
Inspector will have to start serving a four-year jail term for motor
vehicle theft after a drawn-out attempt to appeal against his
conviction was dealt a decisive blow in the High Court last week.
More
than four and a half years have passed since the then Police Inspector
John Lawrence Platt and a co-accused, James Kasume, were convicted on a
charge of motor vehicle theft and each sentenced to an effective four
years' imprisonment on November 8 2000.
In
the intervening years, both men have remained free on bail pending the
hearing and finalisation of an appeal they had lodged against their
conviction.
But on Wednesday, this time of reprieve came to an end for Platt and Kasume.
That
was when Judge Annel Silungwe gave a ruling in which he refused to
excuse Platt's failure to have followed the High Court's rules during
the initial stages of his appeal, and ordered that Platt's bail pending
appeal be cancelled.
The Judge also ordered that Kasume's bail pending appeal was likewise being cancelled.
The two men will now have to start serving their terms of imprisonment.
What
Judge Silungwe described as a "grossly inordinate and indefensible
delay" by both Platt and his former legal representative in pursuing
the appeal swayed the Judge to dismiss Platt's efforts to revive his
appeal after it had been struck off the High Court's roll in June
2002.In any event, Judge Silungwe added, it would appear on the face of
the evidence that was produced during Platt's trial in the Windhoek
Regional Court that the prospects for a successful appeal were slim.
Judge Nic Hannah concurred with Judge Silungwe's decision.
Platt
and Kasume were accused of having stolen a Mazda 323 vehicle, valued at
some N$17 000, in Windhoek between August 27 and September 3 1998.
The vehicle was recovered at a farm in the Rehoboth area on the latter date.
Both Platt and Kasume lodged an appeal two days after their conviction and sentencing.
However, when the appeal had to be heard in the High Court on June 3 2002, their lawyers were not present.
The appeal was struck from the roll.
According to Platt, he learned only in August the next year that his appeal had been unsuccessful.
Judge
Silungwe commented in his judgement that it was apparent that in the
period between June 2002 and August 2003 neither Platt nor his lawyer
had played any meaningful role in the prosecution of the appeal.
It
is because of that "grossly inordinate and indefensible delay",
evidenced by an "ordinate period of inactivity" on Platt's part, that
the Judges decided not to condone his non-compliance with the High
Court's rules.
|